教学视频中前嵌问题与反馈对学习的影响研究Effects of in-video questions and answers on learning performance
谢耀辉,杨九民,皮忠玲,戴晨艳,刘彩霞
摘要(Abstract)：
采用眼动实验方法考察教学视频中前嵌问题与反馈设计对注意分配和学习成绩的影响,以及是否存在经验反转效应。49名高先前知识经验学习者与45名低先前知识经验学习者同时学习了含有无前嵌问题、前嵌问题无反馈与前嵌问题有反馈的教学视频。研究发现,前嵌问题无反馈不仅能提高学习者对教学内容的注意程度,还能提高学习成绩。此外,教学视频中前嵌问题与无反馈设计对学习成绩的影响中发生了经验反转效应,即前嵌问题无反馈的教学视频只提高了低知识经验学习者的学习成绩,但没有提高高知识经验学习者的学习成绩。研究发现为教学视频的设计策略提供了有益的参考。
关键词(KeyWords)： 教学视频;前嵌问题;反馈;先前知识经验;学习成绩;视觉注意;经验反转效应;眼动追踪
基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金面上项目“社会性交互对视频课程教与学影响的认知神经机制与应用研究”（项目编号：61877024）;; 教育部人文社科研究规划基金项目“教学视频中具身线索影响学习的认知神经机制与应用研究”（19XJC880006）的研究成果
作者(Author): 谢耀辉,杨九民,皮忠玲,戴晨艳,刘彩霞
DOI: 10.13541/j.cnki.chinade.2021.12.006
参考文献(References)：
- 储衡清，周晓林.2004.注意捕获与自上而下的加工过程[J].心理科学进展(5):680-687.
- 李文静，童钰，王福兴，等.2016.动画教学代理对多媒体学习的影响：学习者经验与偏好的调节作用[J].心理发展与教育，32(4):453-462.
- 联合国教科文组织.2020-05-07.新冠肺炎疫情对教育的影响[EB/OL].[2020-05-07].https：//zh.unesco.org/themes/education-emergencies/coronavirus-school-closures
- 梁秀玲，李鹏，陈庆飞，等.2015.提取学习有利于学习与记忆的认知神经基础[J].心理科学进展，23(7):1151-1159.
- 罗良，张玮.2012.利用测试促进学习：记忆心理学的研究进展与教育启示[J].北京师范大学学报(社会科学版)(1):43-50.
- 施良方.2001.学习论[M].北京：人民教育出版社：221.
- 舒少全.2016.交互式教学视频中问题的反馈内容对大学生学习效果的影响[D].武汉：华中师范大学.
- 王福兴，段朝辉，周宗奎.2013.线索在多媒体学习中的作用[J].心理科学进展，21(8):1430-1440.
- 谢和平，王福兴，周宗奎，等.2016.多媒体学习中线索效应的元分析[J].心理学报，48(5):540-555.
- 袁启林.2015.创设问题情境引发认知冲突建构物理概念--浅析“摩擦力”教学案例[J].物理教师，36(9):9-10.
- 张锦坤，杨丽娴.2011.测试效应：致力于有效学习的一项基础研究[J].心理科学，34(5):1101-1105.
- 周爱保，杨天成，程晨，等.2015.多篇章学习中提取练习策略对高阶技能的影响[J].心理学报，47(7):928-938.
- Arslan-Ari,I.(2018).Learning from instructional animations:How does prior knowledge mediate the effect of visual cues?Journal of Computer assisted Learning,34(2),140-149.
- Boer,J.D.,Kommers,P.A.M.,Brock,B.D.,&Tolboom,J.(2014).The influence of prior knowledge and viewing repertoire on learning from video.Education and Information Technologies,21(5),1135-1151.
- Callender,A.A.,&Mcdaniel,M.A.(2007).The benefits of embedded question adjuncts for low and high structure builders.Journal of Educational Psychology,99(2),339-348.
- Carpenter,S.K.(2009).Cue strength as a moderator of the testing effect:the benefits of elaborative retrieval.Journal of Experimental Psychology Learning Memory&Cognition,35(6),1563-1569.
- Carpenter,S.K.,&Toftness,A.R.(2017).The effect of prequestions on learning from video presentations.Journal of Applied Research in Memory&Cognition,6(1),104-212.
- Choi,H.J.,&Johnson,S.D.(2005).The effect of context-based video instruction on learning and motivation in online courses.The American Journal of Distance Education,19(4),215-227.
- Filius,R.M.,Kleijn,R.A.M.,Uijl,S.G.,Prins,F.J.,Van,R.H.V.M.,&Grobbee,D.E.(2018).Strengthening dialogic peer feedback aiming for deep learning in spocs.Computers&Education,125(OCT.),86-100.
- Gordon,L.T.,Thomas,A.K.,&Bulevich,J.B.(2015).Looking for answers in all the wrong places:how testing facilitates learning of misinformation.Journal of Memory&Language,83,140-151.
- Higgins,R.,Hartley,P.,&Skelton,A.(2002).The conscientious consumer:Reconsidering the role of assessment feedback in student learning.Studies in Higher Education,27(1),53-64.
- Homer,B.D.,&Plass,J.L.(2010).Expertise reversal for iconic representations in science visualizations.Instructional Science,38(3),259-276.
- Huff,M.J.,Weinsheimer,C.C.,&Bodner,G.E.(2016).Reducing the misinformation effect through initial testing:take two tests and recall me in the morning?.Applied Cognitive Psychology,30(1),61-69.
- Hung,I.C.,&Chen,N.S.(2018).Embodied interactive video lectures for improving learning comprehension and retention.Computers&Education,117,116-131.
- Jordan,S.(2012).Student engagement with assessment and feedback:Some lessons from short-answer free-text e-assessment questions.Computers&Education,58(2),818-834.
- Kalyuga,S.(2014).Prior knowledge principle in multimedia learning.In R.E.Mayer (Ed.),The Cambridge handbook of multimedia learning(pp.576-597).New York,NY:Cambridge University Press.
- Kalyuga,S.,Chandler,P.,&Sweller,J.(2000).Incorporating learner experience into the design of multimedia instruction.Journal of Educational Psychology,92,126-136.
- Kalyuga,S.,Rikers,R.,&Paas,F.(2012).Educational implications of expertise reversal effects in learning and performance of complex cognitive and censorimotor skills.Educational Psychology Review,24(2),313-337.
- Khacharem,A.,Zoudji,B.,&Kalyuga,S.(2015).Expertise reversal for different forms of instructional designs in dynamic visual representations.British Journal of Educational Technology,46(4),756-767.
- Khacharem,A.,Spanjers,I.A.E.,Zoudji,B.,Kalyuga,S.,&Ripoll,H.(2013).Using segmentation to support the learning from animated soccer scenes:an effect of prior knowledge.Psychology of Sport and Exercise,14,154-160.
- Kluger,A.,&Denisi,A.(1996).The effects of feedback interventions on performance:A historical review,a meta-analysis,and a preliminary feedback intervention theory.Psychological Bulletin,119(2),254-284.
- Lee,H.,Plass,J.L.,&Homer,B.D.(2006).Optimizing cognitive load for learning from computer-based science simulations.Journal of Educational Psychology,98,902-913.
- Little,J.L.,&Bjork,E.L.(2016).Multiple-choice pretesting potentiates learning of related information.Memory&Cognition,44(7),1085-1101.
- Mory,E.H.(2004).Feedback research revisited.In D.H.Jonassen(Ed.),Handbook of research on educational communications and technology (pp.125-143).Mahwah,NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers.
- Pi,Z.,Hong,J.,&Yang,J.(2017).Effects of the instructor’s pointing gestures on learning performance in video lectures.British Journal of Educational Technology,48(4),1020-1029.
- Plass,J.L.,Homer,B.D.,&Hayward,E.(2009).Design factors for educationally effective animations and simulations.Journal of Computing in Higher Education,21(1),31-61.
- Plass,J.L.,Homer,B.D.,Chang,Y.K.,Barrientos,J.Milne,C.,Jordan,T.,et al.(2007,October).Representational mode and cognitive load:optimizing the instructional design of science simulations.Annual convention of the Association for Educational Communication and Technology (AECT),California,USA.
- Price,M.,Handley,K.,Millar,J.,&O’donovan,B.(2010).Feedback:all that effort,but what is the effect?.Assessment&Evaluation in Higher Education,35(3),277-289.
- Rahim,R.A.,Noor,N.M.,&Zaid,N.M.(2014,December).Development of video based on Cognitive Conflict Strategies in learning Information Technology Application and Communication subject.IEEE 6th Conference on Engineering Education,Kuala Lumpur,Malaysia.
- Rahim,R.A.,Noor,N.M.,&Zaid,N.M.(2015).Meta-analysis on Element of Cognitive Conflict Strategies with a Focus on Multimedia Learning Material Development.International Education Studies,8(13),73-78.
- Rawson,K.A.,Vaughn,K.E.,&Carpenter,S.K.(2015).Does the benefit of testing depend on lag,and if so,why?Evaluating the elaborative retrieval hypothesis.Memory&Cognition,43(4),619-633.
- Roberts,K.J.,Revenson,T.A.,Urken,M.L.,Fleszar,S.,Cipollina,R.,Rowe,M.E.,et al.(2016).Testing with Feedback Improves Recall of Information in Informed Consent:A Proof of Concept Study.Patient Education and Counseling,99(8),1377-1381.
- Roediger,H.L.,&Karpicke,J.D.(2006).The Power of Testing Memory:Basic Research and Implications for Educational Practice.Perspectives on Psychological Science A Journal of the Association for Psychological Science,1(3),181-210.
- Spanjers,I.A.E.,Wouters,P.,van Gog,T.,&van Merri?nboer,J.J.G.(2011).An expertise reversal effect of segmentation in learning from animations.Computers in Human Behavior,27,46-52.
- Szpunar,K.K.,Khan,N.Y.,&Schacter,D.L.(2013).Interpolated memory tests reduce mind wandering and improve learning of online lectures.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,110(16),6313-6317.
- Wachtler,J.,Geier,G.,&Ebner,M.(2015).Digital Medien in Arbeitsund Lernumgebungen.In Jost,P.,&Künz,A.(Ed.).Design and Evaluation of a User Interface for an Interaction Supported Video Platform(pp.117-124).Pabst,Lengrich.